This page explains how Pixel Herald reviews games: who writes our reviews, how we play, how we score, and what we disclose. It applies to every post labeled “Review” with a score. Our general rules for news, sourcing and corrections are in our Editorial Standards.
Reviews are written by people who played the game
- Every scored review is written by a named critic who played the game themselves. The critic’s name is on the review and links to their author page.
- We play enough of a game to judge it fairly. For story-driven games that usually means finishing the main story; for open-ended, live-service or multiplayer games, we play long enough to see how it holds up, and we say how far we got.
- We name the platform we played on. If a game performs differently on other platforms and we haven’t tested them, we say so.
- AI tools are not used to write reviews, generate impressions, or decide scores. The opinions in a review are the critic’s own.
How we score
We score games on a 10-point scale, in whole numbers. The full range is in use, and a score reflects the game as a whole at the time we played it.
| Score | What it means |
|---|---|
| 10 | Masterpiece. A defining game for its genre or generation. Flaws, if any, don’t take away from it. |
| 9 | Exceptional. An easy recommendation with only minor issues. |
| 8 | Great. Clearly worth playing, with some flaws you’ll notice. |
| 7 | Good. Enjoyable and solid, but held back by real problems. |
| 6 | Decent. Worth it for fans of the genre or series; others can wait. |
| 5 | Mixed. Its strengths and weaknesses roughly cancel out. |
| 4 | Poor. Some good ideas, but hard to recommend. |
| 3 | Bad. Major problems in most areas. |
| 1–2 | Broken or not worth anyone’s time. |
Games scored 7 or higher count as “recommended” on review aggregators. Every review ends with a short verdict and its score, so you can see our conclusion at a glance.
Review copies and disclosure
- Sometimes publishers send us review codes; other times we buy the game. Each review says which.
- A review code never comes with conditions on what we say or what score we give. If a publisher asks for that, we decline the code.
- We honor review embargoes on timing, but embargoes never change the content of a review.
- We don’t accept payment, gifts or trips in exchange for coverage. If a publisher ever covers travel or provides hardware for a review, the review will say so.
- Some posts include affiliate links to stores, which may earn us a small commission. Affiliate links and advertising never influence a review or its score.
Updates, patches and re-reviews
Games change after launch. If a patch fixes or breaks something important, we may add a dated update note to the review. We only change a score if the game has changed substantially, and when we do, we note the original score, the new score, the date and the reason.
Reviews vs. review roundups
Pixel Herald also publishes Reviews Roundups, which summarize what other critics are saying about a game and link to their reviews. Roundups are labeled as roundups, carry no Pixel Herald score, and don’t claim first-hand play.
Contact
Publishers and PR can send review codes through our contact page; please include the platform and any embargo. Readers who think a review got something wrong can reach us the same way.